Nolan Arenado a name synonymous with elite defense and potent offensive production, has solidified his reputation as one of the St. Louis Cardinals’ most valuable assets. However, as the 2025 season unfolds, his stellar reputation is being challenged by a series of controversies and an underwhelming start to the year. Despite his undeniable talent, Arenado’s performance has not been up to his usual standards, causing concern among fans and analysts alike.
Arenado, who joined the Cardinals in 2021, quickly became a fan favorite and a crucial part of their lineup. His Gold Glove-caliber defense at third base and consistent power at the plate made him a standout. With multiple seasons of 30+ home runs and a reputation as one of the game’s best defensive players, Arenado’s presence on the field has been a beacon of consistency.
However, the 2025 season has not been kind to Arenado. His offensive numbers have dipped, with fewer home runs and a lower batting average than expected. Fans have also voiced frustrations over his recent inconsistency, particularly in key moments. These struggles come amid mounting internal pressure within the Cardinals organization, as the team grapples with overall underperformance and a challenging season that has left many questioning the direction of the franchise.
On top of his on-field difficulties, Arenado has also found himself at the center of controversy. Trade rumors have swirled, with some suggesting that the Cardinals may look to move the star player, given the team’s struggles and financial considerations. This uncertainty has further added to the pressure surrounding Arenado, as his leadership and future with the team hang in the balance.
Despite the turbulence, Arenado’s pedigree as one of the game’s best remains intact. How he responds to the adversity could define not only his season but his legacy with the Cardinals.